CCT-K7, EUROMET.T-K7, COOMET.T-K7, EURAMET.T-K7.1, EURAMET.T-K7.2, EURAMET.T-K7.3, APMP.T-K7.1 and EURAMET.T-K7.4

 

MEASURAND   Temperature of triple point of water

NOMINAL VALUE 273.16 K

Degrees of equivalence represented by Di = (xi - xR) and its expanded uncertainty Ui at a 95 % level of confidence, both expressed in μK.

Water triple point cells
Di / µK
Participating institutes

Click here for enlarged graph.

CCT-K7, EUROMET.T-K7, COOMET.T-K7, EURAMET.T-K7.1, EURAMET.T-K7.2, EURAMET.T-K7.3, APMP.T-K7.1 and EURAMET.T-K7.4

 

MEASURAND   Temperature of triple point of water

NOMINAL VALUE 273.16 K

Degrees of equivalence represented by Di = (xi - xR) and its expanded uncertainty Ui at a 95 % level of confidence, both expressed in μK.

LABi Di Uneg,i Upos,i
µK
µK
µK
BIPM -22 90
LNE-LCM/Cnam -76 134
CEM -36 85
CENAM -27 58
NMISA 83 150
NMIA -51 72
INRIM -37 58
IPQ 18 322
KRISS 47 115
MSL 95 39
NIM 11 124
NIST -62 69
NMIJ 32 304
VSL -6 113
NPL 23 81
NRC 62 52
PTB -37 113
SMU 47 109
NMC, A*STAR 11 144
UME -75 183
VNIIM 0 94
INM 46 136
MKEH -28 145
EIM 95 230
MIKES 33 137
PTB 88 86
DTI -2 145
JV -97 390
VNIIM 112 113
DZM/LPM 59 110
UME -37 161
DMDM -101 242
BEV 29 352
NSAI NML 89 212
CMI -261 130
GUM -260 155
FTMC -13 243
INRIM 51 73
MIRS/FE-LMK 82 68
SMD 94 82
BelGIM 50 172
GEOSTM -95 345
NISM 47 242
INIMET -43 191
NSC IM -19 249
KazInMetr -102 215
SMU 52 149
CMI 73 206
INTiBS 66 118
GUM 75 140
VMI-STAMEQ 43 286
EMI 35 114
SASO -182 221
IMBIH -29 189
Participating institutes
CCT-K7
EUROMET.T-K7
COOMET.T-K7
EURAMET.T-K7.1
EURAMET.T-K7.2
EURAMET.T-K7.3
APMP.T-K7.1
EURAMET.T-K7.4
COOMET.T-K7
Metrology area, Sub-field Thermometry, Fixed Point Cells
Description Comparison of water triple point cells
Time of measurements 2008 - 2011
Status Approved for equivalence
Final Reports of the comparisons
Measurand Temperature: 273.16 K
Transfer device Water triple point cells
Comparison type Key Comparison
Consultative Committee CCT (Consultative Committee for Thermometry)
Conducted by COOMET (Euro-Asian Cooperation of National Metrological Institutions)
RMO Internal Identifier COOMET 395/BY/07
Comments Results published on 22 May 2012
EUROMET.T-K7, EURAMET.T-K7.2, EURAMET.T-K7.3, EURAMET.T-K7.1, COOMET.T-K7 and APMP.T-K7.1 results are linked to those of CCT-K7
Comparison of water triple point cells
Pilot institute BelGIM
Belarussian State Institute for Metrology
Belarus
Contact person Dikun Tamara Iosifovna

+375 17 233 04 21
First Name Last Name
wwww@ww.www +356719836 Institute 1 Institute 1 Khmelnitskiy
Pilot laboratory
BelGIM

Belarussian State Institute for Metrology, Belarus, COOMET

GEOSTM

Georgian National Agency for Standards and Metrology, Georgia, EURAMET

INIMET

Instituto Nacional de Investigaciones en Metrologia, Cuba, COOMET

KazStandard

Kazakhstan Institute of Standardization and Metrology, Kazakhstan, COOMET

NISM (now NMI (MD))

National Institute of Standardization and Metrology (now The National Metrology Institute of the Republic of Moldova), Moldova, Republic of, EURAMET

NSC IM

National Scientific Centre "Institute of Metrology", Ukraine, EURAMET

VNIIM

D.I. Mendeleyev Institute for Metrology, Rosstandart, Russian Federation, COOMET

CCT-K7, EUROMET.T-K7, COOMET.T-K7, EURAMET.T-K7.1, EURAMET.T-K7.2, EURAMET.T-K7.3, APMP.T-K7.1 and EURAMET.T-K7.4

 

MEASURAND   Temperature of triple point of water

NOMINAL VALUE 273.16 K

 

The key comparison reference value, xR, is calculated as the arithmetic mean of the results, xi, from all participants, including some laboratories who made corrections for the influence of chemical impurities and isotopic composition, and some who did not.
xR = 22 µK (expressed as the difference from the BIPM value).
The uncertainty of xR, uR, is calculated as the standard deviation of the mean of the data set. uR = 11 µK.
Because the distribution of the pooled data is multimodal, care should be taken when using this quantity for calculating confidence intervals.

The degree of equivalence of laboratory i with respect to the key comparison reference value is given by a pair of terms:
Di = (xi - xR) and its expanded uncertainty Ui (k = 2), both expressed in µK.
The uncertainty includes the participant's uncertainty, the comparison uncertainty and the uncertainty of the key comparison reference value.

The degree of equivalence between two laboratories i and j is given by a pair of terms:
Dij = (Di - Dj) = (xi - xj) and its expanded uncertainty Uij (k = 2), both expressed in µK. The uncertainty includes both participants' uncertainties and twice the comparison uncertainty.

 

EUROMET.T-K7

The EUROMET reference value referred to the NMi-VSL reference cell (VSL-094),
xR EUR, and its standard uncertainty, uR EUR, are computed from the weighted mean of the individual results, with the exclusion of the CMI and GUM results, as explained in Section 7.1 on page 29 of the
EUROMET.T-K7 Final Report:
xR EUR = 15.6 µK, and uR EUR = 10.5 µK

The degree of equivalence of laboratory i, participant in EUROMET.T-K7, with respect to the EUROMET reference value is given by a pair of terms: DiEUR = xiEUR - xR EUR, and its expanded uncertainty UiEUR (k = 2), both expressed in µK.

 

Linking EUROMET.T-K7 to CCT-K7

The linkage process of EUROMET.T-K7 results to those of CCT-K7 is explained in Section 7.3 on page 36 of the EUROMET.T-K7 Final Report. It is based on the common participation of CEM, IPQ, LNE-INM, NMi-VSL, and SMU in both comparisons.

The degree of equivalence of laboratory i, participant in EUROMET.T-K7, with respect to the CCT-K7 key comparison reference value is given by a pair of terms:
Di = DiEUR + dLINK with dLINK = 64.7 µK, and its expanded uncertainty (k = 2)
Ui = 2[(UiEUR/2)2 + (uLINK)2]1/2, with uLINK = 19.7 µK, both expressed in µK.

Pair-wise degrees of equivalence are computed inside EUROMET (see Section 7.2 on page 30 of the EUROMET.T-K7 Final Report).

 

Linking EURAMET.T-K7.2 to CCT-K7

The degree of equivalence of INTiBS relative to the CCT-K7 key comparison reference value is computed through the common participation of VSL in EURAMET.T-K7.2 and EUROMET.T-K7 (see Section 6 of the EURAMET.T-K7.2 Final Report).

 

Linking EURAMET.T-K7.3 to CCT-K7

The degree of equivalence of GUM relative to the CCT-K7 key comparison reference value is computed through the common participation of VSL in EURAMET.T-K7.3 and EUROMET.T-K7 (see Sections 6 and 7 of the EURAMET.T-K7.3 Final Report).

 

Linking EURAMET.T-K7.1 to CCT-K7

New degrees of equivalence relative to the CCT-K7 key comparison reference value are obtained in EURAMET.T-K7.1 for SMU and CMI, through the common participation of SMU in EURAMET.T-K7.1 and EUROMET.T-K7, taking into account the change of national reference cell at SMU since the completion of EUROMET.T-K7.

 

Linking COOMET.T-K7.3 to CCT-K7

The linkage process of COOMET.T-K7 results to those of CCT-K7 is explained in Section 6 of the COOMET.T-K7 Final Report. It is based on the common participation of VNIIM in both comparisons

The degree of equivalence of laboratory i, participant in COOMET.T-K7, with respect to the CCT-K7 reference value is given by a pair of terms: Di, and its expanded uncertainty (k = 2) Ui, both expressed in µK.

No pair-wise degrees of equivalence are computed inside COOMET.T-K7.

 

Linking APMP.T-K7.1 to CCT-K7

The degree of equivalence of VMI-STAMEQ relative to the CCT-K7 key comparison reference value is computed through the common participation of NMIJ in APMP.T-K7 and CCT-K7 (see Section 8 of the APMP.T-K7.1 Final Report).

 

Linking EURAMET.T-K7.4 to CCT-K7

UME provides the link between the key comparison CCT-K7 and EURAMET.T-K7.4, having participated in both comparisons. The linking process is described in Section 9 of the EURAMET.T-K7.4 Final report.

 

CCT-K7, EUROMET.T-K7, COOMET.T-K7, EURAMET.T-K7.1, EURAMET.T-K7.2, EURAMET.T-K7.3, APMP.T-K7.1 and EURAMET.T-K7.4

 

MEASURAND   Temperature of triple point of water

NOMINAL VALUE 273.16 K

 

 

CCT-K7

 

xi : temperature difference between the national reference of laboratory i and the BIPM reference, xi = T(Lab i) - T(BIPM), where T is the temperature
ui : combined standard uncertainty of xi

Lab i xi
/ µK
ui
/ µK
     
 BIPM 0 44
 LNE-INM -54 66
 CEM -14 41
 CENAM -5 27
 NMISA

105

74

 NMIA

-29

34

 INRIM

-15

27

 IPQ

40

160

 KRISS

69

56

 MSL

117

16

 NIM

33

61

 NIST

-40

33

 NMIJ

54

151

 NMi-VSL

16

55

 NPL

45

39

 NRC

85

23

 PTB

-14

56

 SMU

69

53

 A*STAR

34

71

 UME

-53

91

 VNIIM

22

46

 

 

EUROMET.T-K7

xiEUR : temperature difference between the national reference of laboratory i and the NMi-VSL reference cell (VSL-094), xi = T(Lab i) - T(VSL-094), where T is the temperature
uiEUR : combined standard uncertainty of xiEUR

 Lab i xiEUR
/ µK
uiEUR
/ µK
     
 INM(RO) -3 64
 MKEH -77 69
 EIM 45 113
 MIKES -17 65
 PTB

39

37

 DTI

-51

68

 JV

-146

194

 VNIIM

63

52

 DZM/LPM

10

50

 UME

-86

77

 DMDM

-151

119

 BEV

-20

174

 IPQ

30

80

 NML(IE)

40

106

 CMI

-310

61

 GUM

-309

75

 VMT/PFI

-62

119

 CEM

51

44

 INRIM

2

29

 LNE-INM

16

56

 MIRS/FE-LMK

33

25

 SMD

44

34

 SMU

-4

58

 NMi-VSL

14

28

 

COOMET.T-K7

The comparison was performed in three stages: 1) each participating laboratory carried out comparisons of the transfer cell with its national standard cell in local conditions; 2) the transfer cells were forwarded together with measurement results to BelGIM, where they were compared with the standard BelGIM cell using its laboratory equipment; and 3) the transfer cells were sent back to laboratories, where they were compared again to the national standard cells in order to determine the stability of the transfer cells.
The measurement results of the participating laboratories are given in section 2, 3, and 4 of the COOMET.T-K7 Final Report.

 

EURAMET.T-K7.2

The measurement results of this bilateral key comparison between VSL (The Netherlands) and INTiBS (Poland), carried out in 2010, are summarized in Sections 3 and 4, on pages 5 and 6 of the EURAMET.T-K7.2 Final Report.
They lead to the following numbers:
TINTiBS Nat. Ref. - TVSL Nat. Ref. = 2.9 µK and associated combined standard uncertainty (k = 1) u = 46 µK, where "Nat. Ref." stands for "National Reference".

 

EURAMET.T-K7.3

The measurement results of this bilateral key comparison between VSL (The Netherlands) and GUM (Poland), carried out in 2011, are summarized in Sections 3 and 4, on pages 5 and 6 of the EURAMET.T-K7.3 Final Report.
They lead to the following numbers:
TGUM Nat. Ref. - TVSL Nat. Ref. = 11.5 µK and associated combined standard uncertainty (k = 1) u = 60 µK, where "Nat. Ref." stands for "National Reference".

 

EURAMET.T-K7.1

The measurement results of this bilateral key comparison between CMI (Czech Republic) and SMU (Slovakia), carried out in 2009, are summarized in Sections 2 and 3 of the EURAMET.T-K7.1 Final Report.
It should be noted that SMU replaced its national reference cell with a cell with known isotopic composition after completion of key comparison EUROMET.T-K7.

 

APMP.T-K7.1

The measurement results of this bilateral key comparison between VMI-STAMEQ (Viet Nam) and NMIJ (Japan), carried out in 2014 - 2015, are summarized in Sections 3 to 6 of the APMP.T-K7.1 Final Report.
They lead to the following numbers:
TVMI-STAMEQ Nat. Ref. - TNMIJ Nat. Ref. = -19.9 µK and associated combined standard uncertainty (k = 1) u = 46.3 µK, where "Nat. Ref." stands for "National Reference".

 

EURAMET.T-K7.4

The measurement results are summarized in Section 8 of the EURAMET.T-K7.4 Final report.